Saturday, December 28, 2019
Phillips Strategic Analysis - Free Essay Example
Sample details Pages: 11 Words: 3343 Downloads: 10 Date added: 2017/06/26 Category Business Essay Type Analytical essay Did you like this example? This section will consider an analysis of the global LCD industry and the factors within the strategic environment which will have an impact upon the industry. In order to analyse the environment, this section will make use of a PESTLE analysis which considers the relevant political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental factors. Having conducted the analysis, the paper will then present an action plan as to how Phillips may maintain its market share in the industry. Political Political factors may be seen as having a large impact upon the global LCD sector and have had an impact upon both the market and manufacturing aspects of the industry. On the whole, recent decades have seen political moves to essentially open up world markets allowing producers such as Phillips to both retail and manufacture its products in a wider range of countries than previously (Griffin and Pustay, 2010, Krugman et al, 2012). Such political changes often relate to emerging markets such as China, Russia, India and Brazil all of which have taken significant political steps in recent years to attract investment from producers such as Phillips. Despite such reforms, manufacture such as Phillips also need to be aware that reversals of policy are still a possibility, this may be seen as all the more of a risk in these economically turbulent times when there may be sudden appetite on the behalf of political leaders for protectionist measures which favour domestic producers and protection of the jobs of voters. Donââ¬â¢t waste time! Our writers will create an original "Phillips Strategic Analysis" essay for you Create order Economic Since 2007 it may be seen that the world economy has overall suffered from slow levels of economic growth referred to as the global economic downturn. In addition, the future outlook, especially within Western Europe and the UK would seem to remain bleak with the prospect of a double dip recession forecast by many (BBC News, 2012). For the global LCD sector this may mean that producers have had to focus upon a strategy of cost leadership and providing customers with a value for money based proposition rather than looking to develop value added differentiation based strategies. However, despite the global economic downturn which has affected many countries badly, the results have not all been negative. One consideration is that while countries such as the UK and US have been heavily hit, others such as China and the emerging economies have still seen rising levels of wealth and growing middle class (Ravillion, 2010). As such, this would seem to suggest that strategic planners must focus on investing in markets which have been least effected by recent economic events. Social One key issue which many countries have come to see is an ageing population, a trend seen in both the UK and Western Europe (Parliament UK 2012) but also in the emerging economy of China as a result of the long term effects of the one child policy (Hutchings, 2001). However, one interpretation of such social trends is that this could benefit the global LCD business as aging populations come to look for higher quality home entertainments and other sources of diversion which do not require mobility. Other social changes however have seen changing consumer attitudes towards issues of CSR and the environmental impact of products and consumerism in general (Parsons and Maclaran, 2009). In this case, the consumer electronics sector may be seen as facing both challenges relating to current manufacturing practises in Far East locations (Duhigg and Baboza, 2012) but also an opportunity to create additional products and services linked to developments in green technologies and manufact uring practises. Technological The global LCD market itself may be seen as the product of an innovation in technology and replacing earlier technologies based around the cathode ray tube. However, investment in the technology on the behalf of television and consumer electronics producers represents a risk for companies such as Phillips. On the one hand, while direct investment may reduce supply risks, equally there is a consideration that there is a wide level of uncertainty as to how long LCD technology will be the dominant force in the market (Di Serio et al, 2011). Other issues relate to technological developments of complimentary products, or products which make use of LCD technology besides the core television product such as computer monitors and other consumer electronics. One consideration is that LCD producers and users may choose to invest in the development of technologies not associated with LCD production directly but in order to develop a new generation of complimentary products which make us e of existing LCD technologies. Legal In order to develop and improve LCD technologies, there is a requirement for significant investment on the behalf of producers such as Samsung, Phillips, Sony and others in the market. However, one issue in the innovation process is that if such investments are to continue then investors must have their intellectual property protected (Tidd and Bessant, 2009). However, at present, it would appear that such legal protection is applied in an inconsistent way on a global basis. While producers enjoy rather comprehensive protection in developed economies such as the UK, Western Europe and the United States, protection in key emerging markets such as China and the Far East can often be somewhat lacking in substance, this is despite efforts on the behalf of the WTO and other bodies to improve legislation (Griffin and Pustay, 2010, Panitchpakdi and Clifford, 2002). Other legal issues relate to those of the HR perspective, in this case global manufacturing can often see that legal regulations a much lower in emerging economies such as the Far East and Latin America. However, a key question remains so to whether producers should necessarily take advantage of the lower legal regulations of these emerging economies. In some cases, doing so has in the past resulted in negative publicity for those in the consumer electronics sector, with Ravillions (2010) analysis of Apple proving the point. Environmental Recent years would seem to suggest that the supply chains of those operating in the global LCD sector have become more international in nature with greater outsourcing of operations and the marketing of products in a wider range of international markets (Di Serio et al, 2011). While this may benefit the sector allowing firms to reduce costs through taking advantage of the comparative advantage of nations (Porter, 1998), a spate of recent incidents have shown that environmental factors have recently had a negative impact upon the international supply chains of many companies both within and out with the sector. Such examples include the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina in the Southern USA, earthquakes and tsunamis in Japan which had shock waves in the supply chain of Toyota as far afield as the UK and flooding in Thailand and Pakistan (Kollewe, 2011). All in all, recent decades would seem to suggest that environmental factors present significant challenges for industrie s such as the LCD sector which have become increasingly internationalised in recent years. Action Plan Based upon the above analysis it would appear that the global LCD industry faces an uncertain environment with both significant opportunities and threats. As such, the report recommends the following action plan for a producer such as Phillips in order to maintain market share. Cost Strategy: Given the current economic climate and the general attitude of consumers it is recommended that Phillips should focus upon a low cost based strategy. In order to achieve thus the company will need to ensure that costs are reduced at every opportunity so as to see that not only is the company able to offer consumers the lowest priced product, but also so that such a strategy may be maintained in the long term (Johnson et al, 2008). Market Selection: A key to maintaining market share for Phillips may be to consider the amount of effort put into individual markets. In this case, the company may choose to target geographic markets which have shown a greater level of resilience in the con text of the current global financial downturn (World Bank, 2012). For example, Phillips may choose to develop an emerging markets strategy targeting key high growth markets such as China, India, Russia and Brazil in order to compensate for poor performance in the US and Western Europe. The classical approach or approaches of strategic development may be best summarised by Whittington (2001) who brings together a number theories and theorists who take a ââ¬Ëtop down rational approach towards strategic development. In other words, business level strategies are devised by those at the strategic apex of an organisation and are then implemented throughout the organisation. As Whittington (2001) points out, such approaches towards strategy are often suited to larger companies in mature and stable markets as opposed to emerging industries with a dynamic set of competitors. Having considered the classical perspective, the paper will now make the following business level strategi c recommendations on behalf of Phillips in relation to the future direction of the company. In selection an overall business level strategy, firms such as Phillips are presented with a plethora of prescriptive options, many of which are based upon a price v quality based assessment of strategy. Porter (2004) for instance offers three generic strategies based around cost leadership, differentiation and market focus. On the other hand, Bowman (1995) offers eight possible strategies based around differing levels of price and product quality based propositions. In this case, given the nature of the external strategic environment and the current position of Phillips and its strategic resources, the report recommends that Phillips should make uses of an overall cost leadership strategy attempting to offer consumers LCD televisions in the market which represent the lowest possible price. From the perspective of Bowmans (1995) strategic clock this could result in one of three possi ble strategies including a no frills, low price or hybrid strategy. Considering these options, it may be the low price strategy which is of most relevant with a low price coming to meet average product quality and perceived benefits on the behalf of the consumer (Johnson et al, 2008). However, if such a strategy is to be enacted successfully, then Phillips must become the cost leader within the segment. Having identified an overall business level strategy in the form of cost leadership, the next question is what steps must be taken to implement the strategy on the behalf of Phillips. In the first case, classical perspectives on strategy such as those put forward by Chandler (1962) advocated the expansion of businesses and the increasing of the levels of vertical integration. In this case, from a strategic perspective, classical theorists argued that larger vertically integrated companies were able to benefit from larger economies of scale and economies of scope than there s maller counterparts (Johnson et al, 2008). For this reason, the first recommendation of the report is that from a strategic perspective, Phillips should consider expanding the business not through a program of market based expansions but through a process of backwards vertical integration. In this case, Phillips may choose to acquire key suppliers of related components such as LCD panel producers, alternatively the company may choose to expand in such a direction through a process of organic investment in such in house production. Such a strategy would also seem to be consistent with the desire to reduce the power of the buyer and increase barriers to entry within the industry, key parts of Porters (2004) five forces analysis, a model associated with the classical school of thought on strategic management. This would seem to be desirable for Phillips at the moment given the high level of reliance which the company has on key input material providers such as Samsung (Di Serio et al, 2011). Other possible sources of a strategic competitive advantage for Phillips may be to consider further ways of increasing the volume of sales within the business thus helping to create further economies of scale and scope and in doing so aiding the sustainability of the low cost strategy (Johnson et al, 2008). One issue to consider is that of the product range to be offered by the firm, in general terms, larger volumes of production often result in the development of a lower cost base through economies of scale and a reduction in the allocation of fixed costs (Arnold, 2008). However, not all increases in volume based production may be seen as equally as beneficial. For example, in expanding the breadth of the range of products offered by Phillips, those product additions which share common parts and components are likely to reduce the overall cost base of the company on a volume basis. However, introducing new product lines with few common components is likely to add complexity and hence cost to the business model (Slack et al, 2009, 2010). As such, the report recommends that in the future, Phillips should follow a strategy of increasing the width of its product range through related diversifications with the aim of increasing the volume of existing parts and components bought or manufactured within the company. In summary, this section has presented a view in line with the classical planed approach towards business strategy in which Phillips should apply a low cost prescribed business strategy in order to best align the core recourses of the business with the needs of the external environment. In this case a number of recommendations have been made in order to facilitate such an approach including an increased level of vertical integration and in increasing of the breadth of the product range. From theoretical perspective, both of these strategies should help Phillips to reduce its cost base through the generation of further econo mies of scale and scope, thus supporting the business level strategy. At its most basic level, the decision to outsource production is often considered in terms of a short to term cost analysis exercise with a considerable motivation coming from the prospect of being able to reduce costs and thus pass on the benefits to the end user or consumer. However, as Di Serio et al (2011) article considers, while this is true, the application of a number theoretical frameworks including the resource based view of the firm and transaction cost analysis may provide a more comprehensive framework for analysis. In the first instance, the resource based view of the firm considers that firms generate a competitive advantage by taking advantage of sets of unique and internal resources to develop a superior offering from either the cost based or product based perspective. As such, the decision to outsource of in house production is a key one for firms given that this will often be linked to the available strategic resources of the organisation, hence the decision is strategic as well as operational in nature. Transaction cost theory on the other hand considers that there are costs associated with conducting transactions in a market context, in other words there are additional costs of outsourcing production which are not included in the delivered price of a product (Di Serio et al, 2011). Such costs include the risks involved in buying from a market context as well as more practical costs such as those of monitoring suppliers and planning the process of material acquisition. In other words, the application of transaction cost theory may act as a rebuttal to the instant attraction of manufacturers to an outsourcing strategy, highlighting a plethora of problems and costs which may not have been considered otherwise. One key issue which is raised in specific relation to the LCD market but may be seen as applicable to any outsourcing decision is the opportunity f or suppliers to behave in an opportunistic fashion (Di Serio et al, 2011). Such opportunistic behaviour can include making demands for excessive price increases or failure to supply altogether. Such a situation is more likely in markets where there is a limited number of suppliers and hence the power of the supplier is relatively high. In the case of the LCD market, this context would seem to exist with Samsung being almost the sole supplier of key components of the product. Exacerbating the problem is the fact that Samsung is not only a supplier of the product but also a competitor of Phillips in the consumer electronics sector (Di Serio et al, 2011). As such, one key issue for Phillips to consider in the outsourcing decision is to understand the significant risks being taken with regard to security of supply. Other issue which relate to the outsourcing model consider the issue of flexibility, in this case the total impact of the decision upon a company from a strategic p erspective is somewhat debatable. On the one hand, the outsourcing of production should see that firms such as Phillips have a greater level of flexibility of production output based upon the fact that capacity is increased and decreased through a market based procurement decision. In times of low demand, this is beneficial for the company in question given that it does not have to bear the cost of maintaining the fix costs associated with in housed manufacturing operations. On the other hand, in times of high demand, in theory firms such as Phillips should be able to simply buy in the additional capacity needed. However, while this is true in theory, the Di Serio et al (2011) case would seem to suggest that there can be a struggle to gain supplies from an outsourced provider during peak periods in the business or product lifecycle. Such a risk was materialised for Phillips during the course of the Football World Cup when the company struggled to obtain sufficient suppliers fr om outsourced operations. Other strategic considerations for outsourcing operations come from the perception of risk of investing in technologies associated with every shortening product lifecycles. As the Di Serio et al (2011) case indicates, many in the LCD sector including Sony, LG and Phillips chose to outsource operations or create joint ventures in relation to component production simply due to a belief that investment in in-housed production represented a significant risk due to the short term nature of products in the consumer electronics sector. As such, the outsourcing decision may be seen as a mechanism for transferring such risks from manufacturer to supplier. Bibliography Arnold, G. (2008). Corporate financial management. 4th ed. Harlow: FT Prentice Hall. BBC News. (2012). UK economy in double dip recession. Available online at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-17836624 [Accessed on 20/12/12]. Bowman, C. (1995). The essence of competitive strategy. Harlow: Prentice Hall. Chandler, A, D. (1962). Strategy and Structure. Cambridge: MIT Press. Di Serio, L, C, Bento, R, D, Martins, G, S, Moura Castro Duarte, A, L. (2011). Strategic outsourcing? The Phillips case in the LCD TV market. Journal of technology management and innovation. Vol. 6. Iss. 2. pp219-228. Duhigg, C, Barboza, D. (2012). In China, human costs are built into an iPad. Available online at: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/26/business/ieconomy-apples-ipad-and-the-human-costs-for-workers-in-china.html?_r=2pagewanted=all [Accessed on 23/12/12]. Griffin, R, W, Pustay, M, W. (2010). International Business. 6th ed. Boston: Pearson. Hutchings, G. (2001). Modern China. Lo ndon; Penguin Books. Johnson, G, Scholes, K, Whittington, R. (2008). Exploring corporate strategy Text and cases. 8th Ed. Harlow: FT Prentice Hall. Kollewe, J. (2011). Japan earthquake and tsunami forces Toyota to cut production at UK plant. Available online at: https://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/apr/20/japan-earthquake-and-tsunami-toyota-uk [Accessed on 06/03/12]. Krugman, P, R, Obstfeld, M, Melitz, M, J. (2012). International economics. 9th Eed. Boston: Parson. Panitchpakdi, S, Clifford, M, L. 2002. China and the WTO. Singapore: John Wiley and Son. Parliament UK. (2012). Aging population. Available online at: https://www.parliament.uk/business/publications/research/key-issues-for-the-new-parliament/value-for-money-in-public-services/the-ageing-population/ [Accessed in 20/12/12]. Parsons, E, MacLaran, P. (2009). Contemporary issues in marketing and consumer behaviour. Amsterdam: Butterworth Heinemann. Porter, M, E. (2004). Competitive advantage. Export edition. United States: Free Press. Ravillion, M. (2010). The developing worlds bulging (but valuable) middle class. World Development. Vol. 38. Iss. 4. pp445-454. Slack, N, Chambers, S, Johnston, R, Betts, A. (2009). Operations and process management. 2nd ed. Harlow: Prentice Hall. Slack, N, Chambers, S, Johnston, R. (2010). Operations management. 6th ed. Harlow: FT Prentice Hall. Tidd J. and Bessant J. (2009) Managing Innovation. Integrating Technological, Market and Organizational Change (4th Edition), West Sussex: John Wiley and Sons Ltd. Whittington, R. (2001). What is strategy and does it matter? 2nd ed. London: Thompson Learning. World Bank. 2012. Annual GDP Growth %. Available online at: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG/countries/1W-XS-BR-RU-IN-CN?display=graph [Accessed on 28/12/12].
Friday, December 20, 2019
The Success Of The 1980 S - 1648 Words
Introduction The 1980ââ¬â¢s were a period of many different innovations, studies, misfortunes, and explorations in the United States. This was a decade full of outspoken, optimistic and assertive Americans, this was a time for change. It was really a period that kind of refreshed the US and created a more confident country. There were many people that were trying to find a voice for themselves and realizing that people have a voice and it should be used and heard. Not only were things evolving in the music and fashion industry, politics were taking a huge turn, for the better, and the general everyday life of living in this decade was different than any other decade thus far. All about the Eighties To understand theâ⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦The 1970ââ¬â¢s were a very troubled time, and between the 1970ââ¬â¢s and the 1960ââ¬â¢s, Americans lost all trust in the government. The 1970ââ¬â¢s were full of protesting and a lot of fighting for Civil Rights, women fighting for equal treatment, African and Native Americans and also gays fighting for a voice. The journey for equality continues, as does the protesting against the Civil War. President Nixon was in office at this time. The 1970ââ¬â¢s became a decade of love and peace and equality. The first Earth Day was celebrated on April 22, 1970 in hopes that it would help with anti-pollution. The Watergate scandal was huge during this time. President Nixon had his political party break in to the Watergate building to tap phone and steal important documents. He also paid out money to stop the FBI from continuing on the case. After two years of investigating, the impeachment process was in effect for Nixon. He then resigned before that could happen, though On August 9th, 1974 Gerald Ford become the United States 38th president after Nixonââ¬â¢s resigning. He also escaped being assassinated two different times. Though, his presidency was short-lived, and a new president takes office, Jimmy Carter, in 1976. If asked the usual answer to a question like, ââ¬Å"How would you describe the Eighties?â⬠, or ââ¬Å"What do you remember most about the ââ¬Å"80ââ¬â¢sâ⬠?â⬠would probably be along the lines of, ââ¬Å"Big hair, neonShow MoreRelatedEssay about Starbucks863 Words à |à 4 Pagesis over 10 years old and Starbucks has changed since then. 1. In the early 1980ââ¬â¢s, how did Howard Schultz view the possibilities for the fledgling specialty coffee market? What were the most important factors in shaping his perspective and its success? 2. By 1987, Schultz bought Starbucks from its original founders. It has grown from six stores to over 3300 locations. What were the critical drivers of Starbucks success? 3. Why did Schultz think he successfully import the Italian coffee bar conceptRead MoreThe Presidential Election Of The United States1507 Words à |à 7 PagesThe 1980 presidential election of the United States featured three primary candidates, Republican Ronald Reagan, Democrat Jimmy Carter and liberal Republican John Anderson. Ronald Reagan was the governor of California before he decided to run for the presidency. John Anderson was a representative in Illinois and Carter was the incumbent. The lengthy Iran hostage crisis sharpened public opinions by the beginning of the election season. In the 1970s, the United States were experiencing a strainingRead MoreThe Politics Of The 1960s And 1960s1660 Words à |à 7 Pagesdecline; as a low point in American history, and a time of regression in American society. The progressive and liberal values were not positive changes for all Americans, but the changes were coming about nonetheless. However, in the late 1970 s and the 1980 s th ere was a dramatic shift in the themes found in American cinema that reflected the neo-conservative political changes. With the presidency of Ronald Reagan beginning in 1981, American cinema took steps backwards and reflected the ideals ofRead MoreMusic in the 1980s1137 Words à |à 5 PagesMusic In the 1980ââ¬â¢s The 1980s was a decade of revolutionary changes on the music scene. The two major developments were the advent of MTV and the compact disc. Music became more diverse, with new wave, heavy metal, rap, techno pop, alternative rock and the new country sounds. And music became a huge marketing tool as filmmakers, TV producers and manufacturers of everything from sneakers to soft drinks used hit songs and hot performers to sell their products. Search: how pop culture affects teensRead MoreMusic Has Impacted Our World1585 Words à |à 7 PagesStates felt free to achieve anything that they would wanted to. The 1980s reflected the beginning of a period of great income disparity and a focus on affluence was reflected in the music, but ââ¬Å"when it came to music during the decade, nothing was understated, not the sound, not the fashion, not even the charityâ⬠The impact of music on society was greater than what it seemed, so it made people imitate the artistââ¬â¢s lives. Music in the 1980s seemed to be split into two drastically different genres. New WaveRead MoreStrategic Analysis of Nike1213 Words à |à 5 Pageswas founded in 1964, when it was selling shoes to athletes. It grow rapidly through the 1970ââ¬â¢s, and expanded its product lines to produce footwear in the categories of running, training, basketball, casual shoes, and kids shoes. As the bloom faded from the domestic athletic footwear market, the co mpany entered active apparel market in 1978. Nike made a series of strategic decisions in 1970ââ¬â¢s and early 1980ââ¬â¢s, which made it one of the most successful sportswear and equipment suppliers in the world. Read MoreIs Pop Culture Really Mean?979 Words à |à 4 PagesJustin Bieber, The Wop dance, The Fault In Our Stars movie, and several others. Although, if you ask an older generation, you will get different responses from Michael Jackson and leg warmers to The Breakfast Club and all the trends that made up the 1980s. It brings up a valid question, what does pop culture really mean? Pop culture can mean many different things depending on who is defining it. According to sociology professor Tim Delaney (n.d.), ââ¬Å"It is generally recognized as the vernacular or peopleââ¬â¢sRead MoreRonald Reagan Is The Most Influential Man Of The United States1370 Words à |à 6 PagesThe year is 1980. America is in a slump. Unemployment rate is at an all-time high, families and the economy are still recovering from the Vietnam War, and are suffering from the failure of the presidency of Jimmy Carter. The U.S. economy is in the worst state it has been in since the Great Depression - inflation is at 13.5 percent, unemployment is at 9.5 percent and the federal discount rate is at 14 percent. But after 8 years, Ronald Reagan will turn the country inside out, and make the world aRead MoreAmerica s Age Of Hope1541 Words à |à 7 Pages1980-1989: Americaââ¬â¢s Age of Hope From where did the vigor of the 1980ââ¬â¢s come? 1980 to 1989 was a period in the United States which spurred hope for the economy and in the spirits of the people. The 1980ââ¬â¢s were a decade of the American people standing together in tragedy and rejoicing with each other in victory. In 1989, the fall of the Berlin Wall marked the end of the decade and an age of an oppression overseas. America cheered for the freedom of her brothers and sisters in Germany. One highlightRead MoreHip Hop And Rap Music1584 Words à |à 7 PagesHip hop music is one of the most popular genres in present time that rose to prominence in the 1980ââ¬â¢s. The hip hop genre was born in the African American community and has since then changed into what it is today. What most individuals donââ¬â¢t know is that originally rap music did not contain such explicit themes as it does now; such as misogyny, drugs, crime, and violence among others. Many people may wonder what led to the introduction of s uch themes into rap music and why they remained popular.
Thursday, December 12, 2019
Pros and Cons of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Section 18c)
Question: Discuss about the Pros and Cons of the Racial Discrimination ? Answer: Introduction Section 18 of the Australian Racial Discrimination Act 1975 details about the provisions with regards any kind of behaviour which is odious in nature due to race, colour or national or ethnic origin in Australia. The said section came into effect during the Whitlam Government which states that the racial discrimination is illegitimate in Australia. However the said section is a debatable one, due to the various pros and cons it has. Section 18C states that any act is considered to be illegal in the public if the said act is reasonably and in all possible stances will affront or abuse or disgrace or threaten another individual or a group of such individuals and if the said action is done because of race, caste, national or ethnic origin of those being the victim. Cons Of Section 18c Section 18 in its present edifice offers a practical and an eminent stage or else difficult to understand and hateful tones by depicting the unmerited notice of the media as in the case of Jones v Toben (2002). During an interview with ABCs Damien Carrick, Adrienne Stone had said that even though he is ready to consider the fact that the anti- disparagement laws are not essentially in contrast to the freedom of expression, yet there seems to be an actual risk of counterproductive self overpower effects. Specifically due to the said reason, Toben was given a decades chase in the courts, which is an international platform wherein they can narrate their view points and thus enable to change oneself from a person who was basically engaged in the oppression of a religious community to an individual who considered oneself as a sufferer of such a disadvantageous stature. The said problem has lead to the development of the next pros. The section in its present state twists objectives of this type of legislation into supposed willing victims for freedom of speech. It has been correctly understood that if a person is not careful, the media will ensure that a person detests the people who are suffering the brunt of oppression and their attitudes will become pro the oppressors. Such a misrepresentation in thinking would lead people to perceive the things in a manner which is illogical and often is increased by turning oppressors into the perceived martyrs and those who are being oppressed into apparent oppressors (Sherlock, 2017). Many think that categorizing such actions of an individual against another into the heading of illegitimate is a stupidity. The law passed is too broad in nature but the bar it sets is not up to the mark. The said act is defined as inadequate as it states that the trigger for section 18C should not happen if a speech merely offends or insults another individual. Thus inclusion of such words makes it very easy for anyone to file a suit against another person. The feeling of insult should not be reason enough to put restrictions on freedom of ones speech. The section is framed in such a manner that it puts legal obligations as well as punishments for such issues which are far from being considered as serious (Holmes, 2014). Thus it does not refer to any such speech which can cause hatred and concentrates upon petty issues. Therefore it is not written down in a manner to deal with to the point notions. Thus one can say that the said Section is not consistent under the Australian Constitution. Therefore it is considered to be one of the major threats to the freedom of speech of Australians thereby not paying heed to the other restrictions that exists. Thus due to these restrictions it calls for repealing of the said section as it entirely prohibits the freedom of speech as one is unable to talk about the actual issues such as tax related matters, terrorism or Islam. Further it says that Australias Grand Mufti has demanded for safeguarding the interest of the Muslims similar to the other ethnic groups. Thus the law also demands for inclusion of Muslims protection as well. The ethnic origin has been interpreted as to take into account safeguarding the Jewish and Sikh people but does not specify anything about Muslims. The act can take into account claims of racial detestation construed by the Muslim community. Thus if a person says that he or she had to face hate speeches because they belong to the Muslim community which is beyond their employment status, then their issues are not dealt with by the said Section of the Act (Lewis, 2017). Advantages of Dection 18c However the said section does not only have disadvantages to it, but also has certain advantages attached to it which cannot be ignored. There were times in the past when there existed no law with regards how a person would talk to someone else and would not behold to any unacceptable speech given but was simply considered as personal opinion of a person. But fortunately the same had undergone a change with the advent of Section 18C. The past four decades has stated that it is no longer acceptable to discriminate and distinguish people basis their race. As per this Section, individuals are allowed to articulate their views about the benefits of racial criticism laws, however while analysing these claims and calls for curtailment of two things should be adhered to i.e. around 88 percent of the people who voted in the Fairfax-Nielson poll in the year 2014 stated that people should not be allowed to malign other basis their race, ethnicity and national origin. Secondly, it is blurred as to what does section 18C permit a person to behave like in public (McNamara, 2016). Further to this the section has undergone certain changes over the years which make it more favourable serving the main crux behind implementation of the same. It would be unjust to read section 18C without considering section 18D. The said portion is often forgotten while discussing Section 18C. The political cartoonist are taking the advantage of this flexibility and therefore pushing its limits for decades now. Some individuals are of the opinion that tolerating impoliteness or incivility is a stand of democracy. As per the arguments put forward by Kath Gelber, a social structure has all rights to embrace the basic values at the heart of the democratic ideal of free speech. The same also takes into consideration the freedom to express opinion and the advantage of expressing the opinion in a manner which does not give rise to any such debate in the public. The changes in Section 18 which has deleted the word offend and insult and replaced the same with vilify and intimidation makes it more particular thus setting high level for the said section. The said changes would ensure that the law does not punish such crimes which are not very serious in nature (Doig 2016),. A survey conducted by academics at the University of Western Sydney has found out that 80 percent of the Australians are in support of the new regime wherein it concerns about the protection of racial vilification. This shows that the Australians are highly tolerant towards racism. It clearly shows that the people of Australia understand the importance of dwelling in a society that denounces racism and also finds it correct that the laws reflect the value of the people of Australia. It is the law which helps to regulate and streamline the aspects of the society then why should not a law be formed which would help deny and prohibit abuse and harassment that goes against protecting the dignity of the oppressed person. The said Act gives a definition to the laws that Australia is such a continent wher e people are seen equally irrespective of the race thus promoting racial accord. The said amendment in Section 18C has helped to set a stage for the multi cultural community thus enabling zipping of the hatred towards various race found in the bud. The advantage of the said section is that it has helped to balance the freedom of speech and freedom from cultural denigration (Soutphommasane, 2014). Therefore the Section now focuses upon protecting severe and graver issues than the past. Conclusion Thus on a concluding note it is understood that in view of looking towards the previous Section 18C, the changes have been encouraged and accepted wilfully. While applying Section 18C, courts have started to emphasise only on graver crimes and issues rather than wasting time on lighter ones. Due to this less than 3 percent of the racial hatred complaints ever make it to the courts. References: Doig,M., (2016), Free Speech and 18C: A Rationalists Perspective On A Way Forward, Available at https://newmatilda.com/2016/08/23/free-speech-and-18c-a-rationalists-perspective-on-a-way-forward/ (Accessed 28th April 2017) Holmes,J., (2014), Racial Discrimination Act amendments are either stupid or shameful, Available at https://www.smh.com.au/comment/racial-discrimination-act-amendments-are-either-stupid-or-shameful-20140421-zqxlw.html (Accessed 28th April 2017) Lewis,R., (2017), Grand Mufti seeks racial Discrimination Act cover for Muslims, The Weekend Australian, (Online), Available at https://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/grand-mufti-seeks-racial-discrimination-act-cover-for-muslims/news-story/cf45cf93b9a10ae3be431736f2ccd984 (Accessed 28th April 2017) McNamara,L., (2016), Section 18C is an important part of a civilised society and no threat to free speech, Available at https://theconversation.com/section-18c-is-an-important-part-of-a-civilised-society-and-no-threat-to-free-speech-64801 (Accessed 28th April 2017) Sherlock,M.A., (2017), S.18C, Racial Discrimination Act 1975: Free Speech vs Offend and Insult, Available at https://michaelsherlockauthor.wordpress.com/2017/02/23/s-18c-racial-discrimination-act-1975-free-speech-vs-offend-and-insult/ (Accessed 28th April 2017) Soutphommasane,T., (2014), No case for changing race laws, Available at https://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-04-29/soutphommasane-no-case-for-changing-race-laws/5417076 (Accessed 28th April 20
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)